02/02/2013
IS ABORTION MURDER?
IS ABORTION MURDER
MURDER DEFINED
I saw the question when first posed on "Woodrow Guthrie", I actually went to the original site to argue, discuss really, by the time of my third comment I had so many comments personally directed at myself that the discussion was not worth staying, in, I most certainly appreciate those that have followed these threads, without attacking me personally, Thank you.
The US law allows an abortion, an abortion is not defined as murder in law, thus to call an abortion a murder is libelous, it is inflammatory and out right lie, until the law is changed no one should call abortion murder, no one should be allowed to, one should be sued for making such an accusation. Also in such other places where the abortion is allowed. And not only that the law allows it but also because we just don't know what a murder IS!
If we are to go with the point of a malice a fore thought, the accusation fails also here, no one goes to have an abortion or to perform an abortion for the sole purpose and intent to kill, anyone or anything.
LIFE IS A GAME OF CONNECT THE DOTS, IF YOU DON'T CONNECT ALL THE DOTS OR DON'T CONNECT THEM IN THE RIGHT ORDER YOU NEVER GET THE PICTURE
IS ABORTION MURDER?
IS ABORTION MURDER
MURDER DEFINED
David The common law definition of "murder" in USA is "the killing of a human being by another human being with malice aforethought."
Jean at it's most basic level murder is willingly and maliciously taking someone else' life without their consent
Time and again we end up at the same point, an impasse may be, that murder is and unlawful act, as described by the current rules and norms of the society in which we live, I disagree, if I accept this definition then we are saying also that the Inquisition was O.K., that the killings by the Calvinists just may have been acceptable, The Salem witch trails and may be even lynching would be O.K. And thus by extension we could justify human sacrifice, and cannibalism too. Am I taking this too far?
Surely the cannibals had some laws against murder and so did the people offering human sacrifice, If god could ask for, and Abraham be willing to sacrifice his son, then we must assume that some people at certain times in history were correct to offer humans as sacrifice to the deities that they believed in, semantics aside.
It is hard to define murder in the absolute terms, some of it legal and some defined as illegal, as in when the state itself decides to take a life for what ever reason. ALL MURDERS ARE NOT CREATED EQUAL!
Surely the cannibals had some laws against murder and so did the people offering human sacrifice, If god could ask for, and Abraham be willing to sacrifice his son, then we must assume that some people at certain times in history were correct to offer humans as sacrifice to the deities that they believed in, semantics aside.
It is hard to define murder in the absolute terms, some of it legal and some defined as illegal, as in when the state itself decides to take a life for what ever reason. ALL MURDERS ARE NOT CREATED EQUAL!
I saw the question when first posed on "Woodrow Guthrie", I actually went to the original site to argue, discuss really, by the time of my third comment I had so many comments personally directed at myself that the discussion was not worth staying, in, I most certainly appreciate those that have followed these threads, without attacking me personally, Thank you.
The US law allows an abortion, an abortion is not defined as murder in law, thus to call an abortion a murder is libelous, it is inflammatory and out right lie, until the law is changed no one should call abortion murder, no one should be allowed to, one should be sued for making such an accusation. Also in such other places where the abortion is allowed. And not only that the law allows it but also because we just don't know what a murder IS!
If we are to go with the point of a malice a fore thought, the accusation fails also here, no one goes to have an abortion or to perform an abortion for the sole purpose and intent to kill, anyone or anything.
LIFE IS A GAME OF CONNECT THE DOTS, IF YOU DON'T CONNECT ALL THE DOTS OR DON'T CONNECT THEM IN THE RIGHT ORDER YOU NEVER GET THE PICTURE
No comments:
Post a Comment